1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. hydraulic goods lift

Hydraulic Goods Lift vs Electric (Traction) Lift: Which Should You Choose?

Heavy hydraulic goods lift built by Hydro Fabs to carry marble slabs

Before you ask for goods lift quotations, decide what kind of drive you want. The two common choices are a hydraulic lift, which uses oil and a cylinder, and an electric lift, which uses a motor and ropes. Each has a place. This comparison will help you choose the right one for your building and your load.

Short answer

Choose a hydraulic goods lift for heavy loads, short to medium travel, retrofits and buildings with no room for a rooftop machine room. Consider an electric (traction) lift where there is a lot of travel and frequent, high-speed use, which is more typical of tall passenger buildings. The right answer depends on your load, height and how often the lift runs.

How they differ

FactorHydraulic liftElectric (traction) lift
How it liftsPump pushes oil into a cylinder that raises the platformMotor turns a sheave that moves ropes over a counterweight
Best forHeavy loads, short and medium travelLong travel, frequent use, tall buildings
Machine roomHydro Fabs lifts are machine-room-lessUsually needs a machine room or a dedicated space
RetrofitEasier in existing buildings with little extra structureCan need more structure and headroom
Power useDraws power only while lifting; lowers by gravityCounterweight reduces the power needed to lift
SpeedGenerally slowerGenerally faster over long distances
MaintenanceOil and seal checks, hose inspectionRope, brake and sheave checks

The general principles are described in the overview of elevators; your supplier should confirm the specifics for your site.

When a hydraulic goods lift is the better choice

  • Heavy, awkward loads. Marble slabs, machinery, drums and pallets: hydraulics handle high loads smoothly.
  • No rooftop machine room. Machine-room-less designs suit buildings short of space.
  • Older buildings. Retrofits with minimal civil change.
  • A few floors. Short to medium travel is where hydraulics are most economical.
  • Zero-pit installations. Where you cannot dig a pit.

When to think about an electric lift

  • Very tall buildings with many floors.
  • Constant, high-frequency use where speed matters.
  • New construction where a machine room and structural provision can be built in from the start.

A word on hydraulic vs electric for lighter work

Hydraulic lifts suit heavy-duty work. Electric lifts are motor-driven and suit lighter lifting. For light loads between a few floors, a dumb waiter or a small goods lift may be all you need.

Questions to settle before you decide

  1. What is the heaviest load, and how often will it move?
  2. How many floors, and how high between them?
  3. Is there a machine room or space for one?
  4. Is this a new building or a retrofit?
  5. What is your service plan: who will maintain it, and how fast can they reach you?

Tell us your load, travel and site and our engineers will recommend the drive that suits them. Send your site details on the contact page. To see the product, visit the hydraulic goods lift page.

Frequently asked questions

Hydraulic or electric lift?

Hydraulic lifts use fluid pressure and suit heavy-duty work; electric lifts are motor-driven and suit lighter lifting and long travel.

Are hydraulic lifts energy efficient?

Yes. They draw power only while lifting, which keeps electricity use down.

Does a hydraulic goods lift need a machine room?

No. Hydro Fabs hydraulic lifts are machine-room-less.

How many floors can a hydraulic goods lift serve?

From one floor to as many as your building has, depending on the design.

Can I retrofit a goods lift into an existing building?

Yes. We retrofit goods lifts into existing buildings and tight spaces with custom structures.

Keep reading

Request a quote

Tell us what you need to lift, how heavy it is and how high it must go. Our engineers will get back to you with a design and a price.

Send us your requirement

Prefer WhatsApp? Send it on WhatsApp instead.